Tom McFeely at the National Catholic Register notes that the liberal media has a narrow prism in which they see the political issue of abortion: liberals are pro-choice and conservatives are anti-abortion. Therefore, if you believe that you shouldn’t abort a child, then, you’re obviously a political conservative.
McFeely says this is ‘Nonsense.’
The Independent article concerns Pope Benedict XVI’s pending appointment of a new primate of England and Wales to replace retiring Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O’Connor as Archbishop of Westminster.
The article handicaps the bishops the Independent views as the leading contenders, and provides a capsule description that explains where each man allegedly sits on the liberal-to-conservative political spectrum and discusses why this helps or hinders his chances of being appointed.
The fact is, the Pope will be appointing a shepherd of the Church to provide spiritual leadership to the Catholic flock of the Archdiocese of Westminster and to England and Wales as a whole, not a political leader who can be reduced to a “liberal” or “conservative” ideological caricature….
Another foolish aspect of the characterization of Church leaders and Church actions as being “liberal” or “conservative” is the sloppy way the label often is applied by the media. These days it usually refers merely to whether people concur with basic Church teachings on life issues and on sexual conduct.
If they conform with Church teachings, they’re “conservative”; if they don’t, they’re “liberal” — no matter what their respective positions might be on a host of other political, economic or social questions. If that criterion is the standard, even a Catholic social justice icon like Dorothy Day would have to be characterized as “conservative” because of her vehement opposition to abortion.
McFeely is right to point out that some people’s political ideas don’t fit perfectly into the media’s boxes. As McFeely notes, Dorothy Day is a great example.
And it’s true that Dorothy Day is no Wall Street Journal “greed is good” style “conservative.” Though, I wouldn’t call that a conservative, just a materialist.
But just because Dorothy Day is no Gordon Gekko, that doesn’t mean she’s an LBJ-style Democrat. In fact, Bill Kauffman makes a case that she’s a Jeffersonian-style localist against big government and big corporations.
VN:F [1.1.6_502]
Rating: 0.0/10 (0 votes cast)